Insurance marketing Life & health
The only line wherethe regulatorreads your ads
Life, final expense and Medicare marketing operates under three constraints no other line has: a price you cannot raise, a window eight weeks long, and federal rules governing what your ad is allowed to say.
Every other line in this silo is a competition. This one is a constrained optimisation, and the constraints are not set by your competitors.
In personal lines you can outbid a rival by pricing the full book. In commercial you can win on expertise and a renewal calendar. In Medicare Advantage you can do neither, because the ceiling on what you earn per enrollment is set by CMS, published, and identical for every agent in the auction.
That changes the strategy completely. When nobody can out-earn anybody, nobody can out-bid anybody either. The advantage moves to whoever converts better, works the season harder, and does not get their advertising pulled.
-
Constraint 01
A capped price
CMS sets a national maximum compensation amount for Medicare Advantage enrollments each plan year, with a handful of states including California set higher, and renewals running around half the initial. You cannot negotiate past it — you can only write more policies.
-
Constraint 02
An eight-week window
Annual Enrollment runs 15 October to 7 December. Most agencies write the majority of a year's Medicare production inside those 54 days, which makes this the sharpest seasonality anywhere in the build.
-
Constraint 03
A regulator in the loop
CMS rules govern what a Medicare ad may say, what disclaimer it carries, and how soon it must be read aloud on a call. Non-compliant campaigns do not underperform. They get stopped.
Life sits alongside all this with a different shape again: no seasonal cliff, no federal ad regulator, but heaped first-year commission with thin or absent renewals, and underwriting cycles that stretch the time between a sold case and an issued one. Published benchmarks put life close rates several points below Medicare for exactly that reason — the sale is made and then the medical underwriting decides whether it survives.
Which is why we budget the two separately even inside one agency. A single blended target across life and Medicare hides a seasonal business inside a year-round one, and the seasonal one will always look like it is failing in June.
What these leads cost
Priced by the season,
not by the market
The AEP premium is the whole story
Exclusive Medicare Advantage lead
$35–$75
Off-season range across several independent 2026 benchmark reports. Medicare Supplement runs a little higher on stronger persistency.
The same lead inside AEP
+30–50%
Reported lift during the enrollment window, with exclusive qualified leads and live transfers well past $100 at peak.
Exclusive life web lead
$25–$60
Year-round, skewing to Q1. Final expense sits at the lower end; larger face amounts run higher.
Notice what those three numbers describe. This is not a market where price is set by how valuable the customer is — that part is capped. It is set by when you buy. The identical Medicare lead costs meaningfully more in late October than it did in July, because every agent in the country is bidding for the same eight weeks of attention.
Which produces the one arbitrage genuinely available in this line: build the relationship before the season, so that AEP is a conversion exercise rather than an acquisition exercise. Agents who spend the spring and summer producing educational content, running T65 birthday outreach and warming a list arrive in October with people to call. Agents who don't arrive in October with a credit card.
Ranges are drawn from published 2026 lead-market reports and are for orientation only. Vendor pricing varies by state, filter depth and exclusivity, and it moves every season. Re-pull before each AEP.
Eight weeks, all of it at once
Can you actually
work your AEP?
Most agencies plan AEP as a budget. It is really a capacity problem with a budget attached. This works out both.
Look at last year's submitted dates before you guess this one.
Your 54 days
- Enrollments needed in AEP130
- Leads needed in AEP1,083
- Leads per week, for eight weeks141
- AEP lead spend$68,250
- Paid purely for buying in season$19,500
You need 141 qualified leads a week for eight consecutive weeks, and the seasonal premium alone costs $19,500 more than the same volume would have cost in July. Every conversation you can move earlier is money kept and a week of pressure removed.
AEP runs 15 October to 7 December — 54 days, about 7.7 weeks. To pressure-test what you can afford per lead against a capped commission, use the Max CPL calculator.
The block that decides who you hire
You are almost
certainly a TPMO
What CMS requires of anyone marketing Medicare Advantage
Third-Party Marketing Organization rules, 42 CFR Parts 417, 422 and 423, and the CMS Medicare Communications and Marketing Guidelines.
CMS defines a TPMO as an organisation or individual compensated to perform lead generation, marketing, sales or enrollment functions as part of the chain of enrollment. That definition explicitly includes independent agents and brokers. If you are not a direct carrier employee and you market Medicare plans, you are very likely a TPMO — and so is any agency running your advertising.
- The TPMO disclaimer is required across your marketing — website, ads, print, email, online chat and social posts that meet the CMS definition of marketing.
- It must be stated within the first 60 seconds of a sales call. Not at the end, not on the follow-up.
- Marketing materials must identify the plan or carrier. Generic "call now about your Medicare benefits" creative without naming who it is for does not meet the requirement.
- Benefits vary by ZIP, and your advertising has to reflect that. Promoting benefits a beneficiary cannot actually get through the plans you offer in their area is exactly what the rules target.
- Express written consent governs beneficiary data — including, per CMS guidance, sharing it inside your own agency.
- Educational content and marketing content are different things under the rules and should look different, carry different disclaimers and end in different calls to action.
- Keep the paper trail. Approved versions, approval dates, and who signed off. "Everyone runs this ad" has never been a defence.
We deliberately do not print a disclaimer template on this page. The required wording has more than one variant depending on whether you state plan counts, and CMS revises it by plan year — stale mandated language is worse than none. Pull the current text from the CMS Medicare Communications and Marketing Guidelines for the plan year you are advertising in, and have your FMO or carrier confirm it.
This is the section to ask any prospective agency about. If they cannot tell you what a TPMO is, they are going to write you a campaign that gets pulled in week two of AEP, which in this line is the same as losing the year.
Marketing guidance, not legal or compliance advice, and not exhaustive. CMS rules change every plan year and state Department of Insurance rules apply on top of them. Confirm current obligations with CMS, your carriers and your own compliance counsel before running anything. TCPA consent, do-not-call scrubbing and scope-of-appointment requirements are separate obligations this summary does not cover.
Read the market before you enter it
The four advertisers
in life & health
A different four again from personal and commercial. In this line the most useful thing you can note about a competitor's ad is whether it is legal.
-
National direct-response
Big-budget senior lead machines
Television, streaming and paid social at national scale, funnelling to a call centre. Benefit-forward creative, urgency language, and a phone number rather than an agency.
The tell: no named agent, no named plan, benefits promoted without ZIP qualification. The play: this is the creative CMS has spent several rule cycles tightening against. Do not copy it.
-
FMO-supplied agents
Hundreds of agents running identical creative
Carrier or upline-approved templates, distributed to the whole downline. Safely compliant, professionally produced, and completely undifferentiated from every other agent using the same library.
The tell: you will find the same ad, word for word, under a dozen agency names. The play: compliant is table stakes here, not an edge. A named local human beats a template every time.
-
Final expense DR
Aggressive direct response, mostly on social
Emotionally hooked creative aimed at seniors, often heavy on official-sounding framing and programme language. High volume, fast iteration, and the highest compliance risk in the category.
The tell: government-adjacent styling, countdown urgency, no carrier named. The play: study the hooks, refuse the framing. The ones running hardest have the shortest runs.
-
Advisor-adjacent
Planners writing life as part of a plan
Financial planners and advisory firms selling life inside a broader relationship. No urgency, no lead form, long content and a booking link. Playing a completely different game.
The tell: education-first, no product hero, calendar link instead of a quote form. The play: the closest model to what actually works for an independent agent building a durable book.
Run the teardown yourself. The compliance check in step three is the one worth doing first, because a non-compliant competitor is a temporary competitor.
- Open the Meta Ad Library and filter to your state. Senior-market direct response lives here, and run duration is visible on every ad.
- Open the Google Ads Transparency Center for the same advertisers, filtered to your region, to catch the search half.
- Check whether the TPMO disclaimer appears on the ad and on the landing page it points to, and whether a plan or carrier is named. Note every advertiser where it does not. Those campaigns are on borrowed time.
- Note which advertisers only appear between mid-October and early December. Anyone visible in June is building a year-round pipeline, and they are your real competition in this market.
- Separate the educational creative from the enrollment creative in what you find. The advertisers running both, properly separated, are the ones who know the rules.
- Screenshot the three strongest and three weakest and re-run it every August, so the picture is fresh before the window opens rather than during it.
SCREENSHOT SLOT — drop captured Meta Ad Library and Google Transparency images here once you have run the teardown. Pair each with a one-line caption noting whether the disclaimer was present; that contrast is the most persuasive thing on the page.
What the programme looks like
Win the year
before October
The work runs on an annual clock rather than a monthly one. Spring and summer are for content, T65 birthday sequences, community education and list building — the cheap months, when a lead costs what it should and nobody is competing for attention. Autumn is for conversion, capacity and answering the phone.
Compliance review sits in front of everything, not after it. Every asset is checked for disclaimer placement, plan identification and benefit claims before it runs, and we keep the approval record. In a line where a pulled campaign in week two costs you the season, that is not administrative overhead. It is the product.
Underneath sit the same non-negotiables as every line we run: immediate response on inbound, tracking that ties an issued policy back to its source, and a budget ceiling built from your own economics rather than a published average. The full six-step method is on the hub page.
Guide
Exclusive vs shared leads
Sell-through on shared senior leads climbs steeply during AEP, which is precisely when they get least useful. The maths is here.
Read the guideGuide
What insurance leads actually cost
Cost per lead by channel and by line, including why a blended insurance average is useless for a Medicare producer.
Read the guideCalculator
Missed call calculator
During AEP an unanswered call is not a lost lead, it is a lost year. Put a figure on the ones that ring out.
Open the toolNext step
Book it before
the season starts.
Thirty minutes, no pitch deck. We'll size your AEP against your actual capacity, work out what you can afford per lead against a capped commission, and review what you are currently running for the things that get campaigns pulled. Also on the hub: insurance agency marketing, personal lines and commercial lines.